One likes to think - naively, optimistically - that certain principles abide.
Here's one.
Democracy is about engagement. The more citizens are involved in their local communities, the healthier we all are. Neighborhood watch, block parties, community centres, volunteerism - these are among the many signs of a mindful local group who recognize both their privacy and their common ground.
But there are other principles at play.
Like, money.
And, as we always say in Journalism 101, "follow the money."
This bone-headed maneuver on the part of the Vancouver Park Board to seize control of community centres is all about a pittance in cash revenues. It is not only stupid; it is cheesy and small-minded.
Local citizens have volunteered their time and energies for many yeras now to assure that yoga, language lessons, bridge games, tennis, and a score of other activities are available and affordable in their immediate neighborhoods.
It is the lively commitment of these exemplary
involved citizens that make community centres tick.
Now, the august gang of elected thieves calling themselves the Park Board have decided that their bureaucracy can do a better job.
Pathetic. Tragic. A direct hit to the heart of the democratic ideal.
When this story first surfaced, I asked myself once again (This question comes up about once every two years.), "Isn't the Park Board just a part of Vancouver City Government?"
It didn't take long for my old buddy, Allen Garr, to answer that question in the Courier.
And right smartly too.
The penny drops.
Is it time to phase out Vision's Penny?
By Allen Garr, Columnist February 7, 2013
There
is at least one penny a growing number of people in Vancouver would be
happy to see taken out of circulation. That would be Penny Ballem,
Vancouver's city manager.
Vancouver
Vision operatives insist it's nothing but NPA political blarney to
believe that the whole mismanaged assault by the Vancouver park board on
the city's community centre volunteer boards of directors is being
driven by Ballem.
Her Vision Vancouver
political masters may eventually pay the price for this appalling
behaviour. But community centre board members from across the city note
it was Ballem who kept turning up like the proverbial bad penny when she
joined her direct report, park board general manager Malcolm Bromley,
in a series of meetings a few months back. Community centre presidents
and their boards were told the park board would, in a new Joint
Operating Agreement, be taking control of all community centre revenues.
And that was "non-negotiable."
More recently, on
Tuesday evening while Green Party Coun. Adriane Carr was sitting in a
public hearing at city hall regarding a contentious West End
development, her cell phone rang. It was Ballem. Carr would get back to
her at the next beak.
It turns out that on Monday,
Carr, following city council procedure, filed a notice of motion to ask
staff essentially this: given the park board's intention to take over
the revenues of community centres which would most likely dampen future
fundraising efforts by community center volunteer boards, what was the
city's estimation of the funding shortfall this would create for the
park board? And, given that the park board is a department of the city
from whence it receives its budget, what contingency plan does the city
have to make up for that funding shortfall?
A reasonable request based on a reasonable assumption, no?
But
it's also reasonable to assume we will never find out. Because
according to Carr what Ballem phoned to say was this: Carr's notice of
motion would never see the light of day. Carr says she was told that her
motion asking for information could jeopardize the "negotiations" now
going on between the park board and the community centres.
When
I emailed Ballem and asked about her extraordinary move to muzzle an
elected representative, her communications machinery spit out an
elaborate "no comment."
Incidentally, the public
hearing Carr was sitting through Tuesday night under city hall rules
ended at 11 p.m.. It would continue at a later date to hear the rest of
the 50 or so speakers. (The rule says hearings must end at 10 p.m. but
can, with a unanimous vote of council, be extended by one hour.)
Nothing
so civilized was contemplated across town the night before. That's when
74 people lined up to speak in a packed room at the West End Community
Centre. This was at an "emergency meeting" called for by what is an
increasingly inept and disrespectful park board to hear from the public
on the board's plan to have their way with community centre funds. For
decades, these funds had been left in the hands of volunteer boards to
be used for everything from renovations to the creation of new
facilities. That was ending.
The approximately 30
pages of material for the meeting was not available until 11 that
morning, which meant that most board members who work for a living
didn't see it until an hour or so before the meeting started.
As
you may already know, the meeting started at 6:30 p.m. and clattered on
for nine hours, which made it 3:30 in the morning with members of the
dwindling audience repeatedly asking for an adjournment only to be
rebuffed.
It finally reached a sorry state of
frustration because of the lateness of the hour and the vast majority of
the speakers opposing what the park board was up to, frequently
pointing out significant errors in the material being presented. I was
long gone by the time the Vision majority blithely passed the motions to
support what they had intended to do all along and cops had to be
called in to restrain those who were left.
This passes for what Vision Vancouver calls citizen engagement.
agarr@vancourier.com
© Copyright (c) Vancouver Courier
* * *
This morning,
The Sun advises us that City Councillor Adrian Carr has had to hire a lawyer to get simple financial information from her own - our own - government.
Ballem has been a tyrannical autocrat of the worst order from Day One. It is only slightly amusing that such a happy feel-good biking, goat-feeding council should need Axe Lady in their corner. Good cop, bad cop redux.
Let's get a new City manager and let's leave the good folks to run their own pre-natal classes, shall we?