Saturday, January 12, 2008
Homes for Homeless, Tratment for Addicts
Posted by
David Berner
at
10:07 AM
0
comments
Forget the iPOd
Posted by
David Berner
at
10:02 AM
2
comments
Friday, January 11, 2008
A COP SCRUTINIZES HARM REDUCTION
John McKay, a long serving Vancouver Police Officer, wrote this analysis in 2005:
THE FOUR PILLARS RE-EXAMINED
The Four Pillars approach to drug addiction (prevention, treatment, enforcement and harm reduction) is a social experiment developed in Vancouver, promoted worldwide by our former mayor, and hailed as a great success by its proponents. As a police officer working on the Downtown Eastside of this city for the past 4 years, I have had the opportunity to observe this strategy first hand and see beyond the theoretical Four Pillars model to the actual results of its implementation.
The Downtown Eastside, one of Canada’s economically disadvantaged neighbourhoods, is a 12 block area including a population afflicted with unusually high rates of drug addiction and mental illness. There are 130 social service agencies concentrated in this relatively small section of Vancouver which also has a disproportionate share of the city’s social and assisted housing complexes. Among the services available to drug using residents are free distribution of needles (more than 3 million are provided to addicts annually), drug cooking kits, and North America’s first safe injection site.
The philosophy underlying the current situation in the Downtown Eastside is, in theory, the “Four Pillars”. In practice however, the Harm Reduction pillar has been embraced and supported to a far greater degree than the Treatment, Prevention and Enforcement components of the strategy. It is interesting to note that harm reduction is the least expensive pillar to fund and the most supportive of drug use. Harm reduction measures enable drug use and the implementation of this ‘pillar’ through multiple initiatives has given Vancouver’s addicts a sense of entitlement.
The aim of Vancouver’s Safe Injection Site is to provide addicts with a safe place to use drugs where there is access to immediate medical attention if they overdose. In fact, the police officers who work in the DTES 24/7 have observed that most street drug use takes place in alleys just a short walk away from the SIS.
Unlimited free needle distribution is intended to reduce the spread of HIV and other diseases. The unintended consequences of this harm reduction initiative are the thousands of uncapped used syringes that addicts discard in parks and on neighbourhood streets. Because there is no longer a 1 for 1 exchange, users have no motivation to return the needles for proper disposal. Harm reduction for one group causes harm promotion for the rest of our city’s residents. The drugs injected in the SIS are usually paid for by the criminal activities of addicts who are responsible for most of the property crime plaguing Vancouver’s residents and visitors.
Many of the agencies promoting harm reduction are run by earnest, well-intentioned individuals whose objective is to keep addicts alive until they get treatment. Although this is an admirable goal, many harm reduction initiatives damage rather than help the addicts they target. Harm reduction on its own not only can’t help addicts get out of the pit of addiction, it actually digs the pit deeper and wider. On balance, many aspects of harm reduction can actually harm both addicts and non-using members of our communities.
To get a clear focus on the Four Pillar strategy we need to look at it from a broader perspective and examine how such an approach would be applied to illegal activities other than drugs. Effective existing strategies to deal with many criminal activities include prevention, treatment and enforcement. Harm reduction is usually one element included in all of these 3 “pillars.” It is illuminating to overlay the Four Pillar template on non-drug related crimes and observe the role of prevention, treatment and enforcement. This exercise reveals the flawed logic on which our City’s embrace of harm reduction is based.
If we place the Four Pillars template over other crimes, the roles of prevention, treatment and enforcement become clear. In the case of domestic violence [spousal assault], prevention includes violence recognition training and education about the availability of shelters, transition houses and legal protection. Enforcement policies for domestic assault exist in every province and treatment can be mandated for people convicted of spousal assault. These 3 pillars are already in place for domestic violence and all other crimes that society has deemed merit fines and imprisonment.
What then would be the 4th pillar? Harm reduction for domestic violence might mean that the batterer would wear boxing gloves when assaulting his spouse. Boxing gloves would, of course, reduce harm to the victim. Perhaps a ‘Safe Spousal Beating Site’ could provide immediate medical attention for the victims of domestic assault.
To extend the analogy we could consider harm reduction applied in a ‘safe impaired driving zone’ or a ‘safe burglary zone’. These concepts are ludicrous but the extension to a ‘safe rape site’, a ‘safe pedophilia site’ or a ‘safe assault site’ are as chilling as they are inconceivable. The answers to these offenses are Prevention, Enforcement, and Treatment. Harm reduction as a tool in these cases simply does not work. Nor is it a panacea for Vancouver’s drug problems. `
It is my belief that the 4 Pillars approach has placed the cart before the horse. There is no doubt that for effective solutions we must focus on prevention, treatment and enforcement. Harm reduction cannot stand alone. It is already included in the first 3 pillars and its value depends on its connection to prevention, enforcement or treatment. Those elements of harm reduction that are not congruent with prevention, treatment and enforcement should be seen for what they are: pro-drug initiatives which will lead to legalization. If successful, these initiatives will be detrimental to a safe and secure society. As a police officer, I have offered this perspective on the Four Pillars Approach so that citizens and their elected leaders can include it when they are considering the effects of drug addiction on our communities.
Posted by
David Berner
at
8:28 PM
1 comments
Salmon Janet Evening
No doubt, when Premier Clambell produced this pearl of an idea, he was eating shellfish in a restaurant and it suddenly popped out, to the rapturous applause of his ever-applauding, 30 something entourage. One of them perhaps wiped the oyster drool from his chin and put the napkin on Ebay.
But Robson St. is no place for the Clambell shell. It's like hanging furry dice from the mirror of a Bentley.
It's a dumb bell idea.
Posted by
David Berner
at
8:18 PM
1 comments
Thursday, January 10, 2008
David Berner on Vancouver's Misguided Drug Policy (Part 1)
What follows below are 4 videos, each running about 9 or 10 minutes. Together, they constitute a speech I gave last week to the Rotary Club, Arbutus branch. This is a speech I have now given to many similar groups.
I cannot thank enough our friend, Robert Werner, who so diligently recorded this event and transferred it to YouTube and DVD.
Soon, these videos will all be avalable as well under the "Addictions Expert" section of www.davidberner.com.
Posted by
David Berner
at
9:45 PM
2
comments
David Berner on Vancouver's Misguided Drug Policy (Part 2)
Posted by
David Berner
at
9:37 PM
0
comments
David Berner on Vancouver's Misguided Drug Policy (Part 3)
Posted by
David Berner
at
9:35 PM
0
comments
David Berner on Vancouver's Misguided Drug Policy (Part 4)
Posted by
David Berner
at
9:33 PM
2
comments
Shocker - Your New Energy Saving Light Bulb will Cost More
Posted by
David Berner
at
8:29 AM
0
comments
Singh in Sanctuary
Posted by
David Berner
at
8:19 AM
2
comments
Alex Tsakumis on Carole & Sam in Today's 24 Hours
Posted by
David Berner
at
8:15 AM
3
comments
Justice Wallace Craig on North Shore Policing
January 9, 2007
MAKE 2008 a year in which you have your say on the thorny issue of North Shore policing.
Let’s get our three mayors and their fellow councillors out of the wallow of patchwork policing before the municipal elections this autumn.
Before summer days are upon us we must arm-twist municipal incumbents and aspirants alike into declaring whether they will create a civilian constabulary to police the North Shore. And while we’re doing that, our local MLA’s should stand and be counted on the issue.
We need to ferret out the standpoint of each candidate and make sure it is not just a parroting of opinions of senior bureaucrats or the supposed wisdom of outside experts.
Voting is not enough!
With this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity we can produce a collective and democratic decision on policing. In this year you have an opportunity to familiarize yourselves with RCMP paramilitary policing and compare it with local civilian policing. Use shrewd common sense, make your mind up and tell candidates what kind of policing your prefer. If they are uninterested or fail to respond, then go at them with the intensity of a sheep-herding border collie.
We British Columbians, living out our lives in the City and District of North Vancouver, are entitled to be served by an independent North Shore police department in which every constable is our employee and subject to the provincial Police Act.
Beyond that it is time to end the decades-old game of make-believe that “E” division of the RCMP is an actual and controllable British Columbia Provincial Police force.
The British North America Act requires that Administration of Justice be carried out by provincial governments. Administration of Justice includes policing. Yet on a day in 1950 political expediency trumped constitutionality as our provincial government handed over provincial policing to an Ottawa controlled division of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police.
This constitutional impropriety is still with us. If the overall contract with “E” division of the RCMP is renewed in 2012 for another 20 years it will be more than deceitful and misleading, it will be a pernicious act of ministerial misfeasance.
The past year will not slip quietly away. It was a time of intense exposure of outrageous misadventures and weaknesses in our once legendary national police force, now blundering and top-heavy with bureaucrats in uniform. A musty old paramilitary police force so institutionalized that it has been judged incapable of producing a commissioner from within its highest ranks and is now actually saddled with a civil-servant commissioner. Yet at street level in the City and District of North Vancouver, dedicated RCMP constables go about performing their duties with abilities and skills equal to constables employed by the District of West Vancouver.
A North Shore decision to create a civilian police department will certainly reverberate in other urban communities and trigger the implementation of other civilian police departments. That may force our provincial government to end contracting-out of provincial policing and by 2012 to bring back a British Columbia provincial police force to provide rural policing.
I believe that the decision over policing on the North Shore has ramifications beyond our little hillside. It will catch the attention of the federal government and may well cause the minister in charge of the RCMP to withdraw the force from engagement in urban policing and dedicate it to a less visible role enforcing federal laws.
But for us on the hillside it is a grass-roots opportunity to bring change. You can participate in making a decision on a black and white choice: to continue with patchwork policing; or be gutsy and go with one police force from Deep Cove to Horseshoe Bay, one chief constable, a minimal command structure, all officers working out of the police station at 14th Street and St. Georges Avenue in the City of North Vancouver, all of them bound to comply with the provincial Police Act and its complaint process and the governing presence of a North Shore police board.
This is my eighth column on policing. All of them are posted on my website http://www.realjustice.ca/. During the coming months I will write occasionally about police boards, the Justice Institute of British Columbia, the complaint process, and particularly on the cost of policing the North Shore. Contact Judicial Gadfly at wallace-gilby-craig@shaw.ca or by posting your comment directly on the Writer’s Corner of http://www.realjustice.ca/. This column was published January 9, 2007 by the North Shore News.
Posted by
David Berner
at
8:14 AM
0
comments
Wednesday, January 9, 2008
TAX THIS!
Posted by
David Berner
at
11:00 AM
0
comments
Homelessness Revisited
Posted by
David Berner
at
10:53 AM
1 comments
The Co$t of $triving for Perfection
Posted by
David Berner
at
10:41 AM
0
comments
Hillary as Evita
Don't cry me for me, Barak Obama....la la la...
For the ultimate re-hash of Senator Clinton's 2 and a half teary moments, you must read Maureen Dowd in this morning's NY Times.
It's a riot and spot on.
Posted by
David Berner
at
10:34 AM
1 comments
Elizabeth James Finds Us Lost in the Woods
David:
Awake far too early, as usual, I turned to TV Channel 111 locally, mostly for the background music. But then this brilliant news item scrolled by --
"The Federal Government appears poised to introduce programs to provide relief to Canada's struggling forest industry, which has been hit by a double whammy - the rising value of the Canadian dollar and the depressed housing economy in the United States." Nary a peep about the criminally-ignored, decade-plus, devastation of the interior forests of this province, soon to sweep though the Central and South Okanagan tourist mecca.
Where is BC on the map? It's almost as though we don't exist out here.
I thought the Conservative power base was in Western Canada. And where's our own government - besides scribbling about green carbon taxes on the Maui beach, that is?
A good friend of mine - a consultant in the industry - remarked last summer, "Elizabeth, what you have to realize is that forestry in British Columbia is no longer about trees; it's about real estate."
That was confirmed a few weeks ago, of course, by the sell-off of lands in a coastal forestry licence to private interests in Sooke - all given the OK by BC's Minister of Forests.
And where are the people? Heads in the sand, making pots of dough - at ten bucks an hour - in the "booming (paper) economy" of the Best Place on Earth.
And where will they be when our resource-based economy goes bust? Movin' on, Brother; movin' on out.
Elizabeth
Posted by
David Berner
at
10:23 AM
0
comments
Tuesday, January 8, 2008
A New Mayor, Please
Posted by
David Berner
at
8:37 AM
5
comments







